Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Archive for the ‘ComEd Four’ Category

Mike McClain, left, and Anne Pramaggiore | Capitol News Illinois photo by Andrew Adams

By Hannah Meisel | Capitol News Illinois

A federal judge on Monday granted a partial retrial on several bribery counts in the case of four former executives and lobbyists for electric utility Commonwealth Edison who were convicted in 2023 for their roles in bribing longtime Illinois House Speaker Michael Madigan.

U.S. District Judge Manish Shah tossed four of the nine counts on which the “ComEd Four” were convicted, agreeing with defense attorneys that the jury was wrongly instructed in light of a U.S. Supreme Court ruling last summer that narrowed federal bribery law.

But Shah left the other five convictions intact, including on an overarching conspiracy count and charges that the four were responsible for falsifying ComEd’s records to conceal the alleged bribery. Prosecutors alleged the defendants bribed Madigan with jobs and contracts for the speaker’s political allies in exchange for Madigan’s help passing legislation backed by the company.

It’s unclear what will happen next in the case, which was one in a series leading up to Madigan’s own lengthy trial that ended in a split verdict last month. Prosecutors could accept Shah’s order to retry the bribery counts or the feds could appeal his decision to the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals.

But Assistant U.S. Attorney Amarjeet Bhachu, the lead prosecutor in the Madigan-related cases, said Monday  a retrial on the bribery counts may be “somewhat fruitless,” according to reporting from the Chicago Sun-Times. He indicated that the feds may instead want to proceed to sentencing, though he noted he’d need to check with his superiors within the Department of Justice.

Sentencing hearings for the ComEd Four defendants were scheduled for early 2024 but had been postponed after the Supreme Court agreed to review the 2021 conviction of a northwest Indiana mayor who accepted $13,000 from a company that had recently won contracts to sell garbage trucks to the city.

Read more here.

Read Full Post »

Former Illinois House Speaker Michael Madigan exits after the jury delivered a partial verdict in his and former lobbyist Michael McClain’s corruption trial at the Dirksen U.S. Courthouse on Feb. 12, 2025. | Audrey Richardson/Chicago Tribune

By Daniel I. Dorfman | Pioneer Press

Both current and former Illinois legislators are applauding last week’s guilty verdict in the corruption case against former House Speaker Michael Madigan. Now there are calls for additional changes in laws in an attempt to change the state’s lengthy history of political chicanery.

On Feb. 12, a federal jury found Madigan guilty of 10 criminal counts including bribery, wire fraud, and conspiracy. Following two weeks of deliberations after a trial that began last October, the jury acquitted on seven other charges and did not come to a verdict on other counts, including racketeering conspiracy.

With the verdict, Madigan joins a list of many other high-profile Illinois politicians convicted for illegal behavior.

Madigan, who first became Speaker in 1983, started to lose his grip on power several years ago as some scandals reached his office.

State Rep. Marty McLaughlin (R-Barrington) did not serve in the House when Madigan was Speaker but was interested enough in the case that he attended Madigan’s trial one day last fall.

“It was eye-opening to be at the trial and it was disappointing to hear some of the testimony,” he said.

He added, “As a legislator, we should be spending more time on solving problems and less time on backroom deals and phone calls and helping friends out,” he said. “We are supposed to be helping out constituents in the state, we are not supposed to be helping out specific people for inappropriate reasons.”

Read more here.

Related:Darby Hills Appointed as New State Senator for Illinois’ 26th Senate District

Read Full Post »

Former Illinois House Speaker Michael Madigan enters the Dirksen Federal Courthouse. | Ashlee Rezin/Sun-Times

By Jon Seidel, Tina Sfondeles, Dave McKinney | WBEZ, Matthew Hendrickson

A federal jury has found former Illinois House Speaker Michael J. Madigan guilty of bribery conspiracy, bribery and wire fraud in a partial verdict announced Wednesday morning.

The news came nearly 65 hours into jurors’ deliberations in the case against Madigan, who broke records as the longest-serving state House leader in the nation before a widening federal corruption probe forced him from office in 2021.

The panel of eight women and four men listened to more than 60 witnesses and a full week of closing arguments before they began deliberating on the afternoon of Jan. 29. Jurors told the judge in a note Wednesday morning that they had reached a unanimous decision on 17 counts, but were unlikely to be able to agree on another 12.

“We have come to a unanimous decision on 17 counts,” the jurors told U.S. District Judge John Blakey. “We have tried our very best to come to a unanimous decision on the remaining 12 counts and have not been able to do so. It is our belief that this impasse will not be overcome.”

Madigan’s attorney Dan Collins suggested accepting the verdict on the 17 and moving for mistrial on the 12 other counts. Michael McClain’s attorney Patrick Cotter had a similar response.

Prosecutors said they were “amenable to taking a partial verdict.” Assistant U.S. Atty. Amarjeet Bhachu told the judge “the choice is totally” the jurors’ as to whether to return a partial verdict.

Read more here.

Read Full Post »

By Ted Dabrowski and John Klingner | Wirepoints

The Nation’s Report Card that measures how well kids across the country are learning has just been released for 2024. The results for Illinois aren’t good. Here are some top level findings:

  • Just 9% of black 8th-grade students are proficient in math.
  • Only 20% of Hispanic 4th-graders are proficient in math.
  • Just 37% of white 4th-graders are proficient in reading.
  • Overall reading and math proficiencies statewide in both 4th and 8th grades were either the same or down compared to pre-covid 2019.
  • Statewide 4th-grade reading proficiency for all students is down to just 30%, five percentage points lower than in 2019.

The National Assessment of Educational Progress, or NAEP, tests children across the country every two years to assess their reading and math skills. It’s the best apples-to-apples test for comparing education results across states. Nationwide, reading and math results continued to decline in 2024.

Illinois’ NAEP results are yet another indicator that the state’s education system is failing students. Illinois is pouring billions more into education than before the pandemic – $44 billion in 2024 vs. $35 billion in 2019 – yet all the evidence points to that money being wasted. Fewer Illinois students can read proficiently today than could five years ago.

The Illinois State Board of Education downplayed the state’s poor NAEP outcomes by pointing out that Illinois’ 2024 results were slightly up compared to 2022, and that the state’s proficiencies are largely in line with the rest of the country.

But while both are true, what the state board doesn’t mention is just how poor those results continue to be, or that Illinois’ reading and math proficiencies still haven’t returned to their pre-covid levels. Overall, only about a third of Illinois students are proficient in reading and math.

Illinois’ results are even worse than they appear considering just how much more the state spends on education compared to most of the nation. 2022 Census data shows Illinois spent about $21,700 (local, state and federal dollars) on education per student – the 10th-most in the country.

Illinois spends $2,000 to $8,000 more per student than all other Midwestern states, yet its 4th-grade reading results aren’t any better than theirs. Take Indiana for example. 34% of 4th graders in the Hoosier State are proficient in reading, yet the state only spends $14,900 per student, nearly $7,000 less than what Illinois spends.

Illinois’ excessive spending is one of the major reasons why its residents pay the nation’s highest property taxes and one of the country’s biggest overall tax rates. Judging by the educational results of other states, Illinois could return billions of dollars to taxpayers without negatively impacting reading scores.

Read more here.

Read Full Post »

By Ted Dabrowski and John Klingner | Wirepoints

Love Trump or hate him, he won on an agenda to disrupt the country’s broken border, the economy, and how Washington itself works. But even as many Trump detractors soften their stance against him, agreeing that too much has gone too far in America, Illinois is going the other way. Gov. J.B. Pritzker and leaders of the Democratic party are working hard to Trump-proof Illinois. They, their public sector union allies and a friendly media don’t want any disruption of their ironclad control over Illinois, never mind the continuing decline of the state.

Now, we’re not arguing for Trump to come and directly target Illinois for disruption, though we’ll benefit from much of what the president does at the federal level. Disruption at the border, great. We’ll happily accept the relief. Disruption of the massive, distortionary green energy subsidies, also great. Illinoisans’ energy costs have been jumping of late. Disruption of the rules and actions that limit free speech and force feed DEI on our institutions. Absolutely. Good riddance to the cancel culture of the past few years.

But the real disruption Illinois needs is local and Illinois-specific. We don’t need Trump for that. We don’t need the feds. We don’t need outsiders. What we need is for us to do it ourselves. Ordinary Illinoisans disrupting what’s wrong with our state. Dismantling the laws that now make Illinois an extreme outlier on the many fiscal, economic and demographic issues that matter most.

That disruption starts with clawing back the extreme powers that state legislators have given the public sector unions over the last few decades – in exchange for support at the ballot box. There’s perhaps no other state in the country where the politicians and the public unions are more intertwined than Illinois. Take Chicago, where the unions and the politicians have become one and the same: Brandon Johnson is a CTU boss, the head of Chicago Public Schools and the Chicago mayor all in one.

It’s gotten so bad that Illinoisans are now subservient to their public servants.

How about disruption at Illinois’ failed schools, where 1.1 million of the state’s public school children can’t read at grade level? We’ve written ad nauseam about how Illinois’ education system gave up long ago on ensuring kids learn how to read and do math. It’s not an exaggeration, as we wrote recently in Fresh data: Illinois officials graduate record 88% of students despite tragic literacy, numeracy rates.

The disruption must be 100% universal school choice, like what’s happening all around Illinois. Universal choice means any family – of any race and any means – that wants to send their kid to a school of their choice can access an $8,000-$10,000 voucher or an education savings account. Imagine a single mom in Decatur being able to take her kid out of the Decatur Public Schools, where just 10% of all kids read at grade level, and to try instead a private school obsessed with reading and learning.

Read more here.

Read Full Post »

Former Illinois House Speaker Michael Madigan walks through the Dirksen Federal Courthouse. | Tyler Pasciak LaRiviere/Sun-Times

By Jon Seidel, Tina Sfondeles and Dave McKinney | Chicago Sun*Times

‘Like bandits’: Just minutes into Assistant U.S. Attorney Amarjeet Bhachu’s highly anticipated cross-examination Monday of former Illinois House Speaker Mike Madigan, prosecutors played a recording that’s been allowed into the trial only because of testimony Madigan gave last week. The recording shows Madigan laughing as he tells his ally, Michael McClain, that certain ComEd contractors had “made out like bandits.”

Prosecutor’s highlights: Madigan testified last week that he thought he’d sent a message to then-Ald. Danny Solis that he wouldn’t be part of a “quid pro quo.” But Bhachu cited at least five other examples of Solis suggesting such an arrangement.

Meet the prosecutor: Bhachu is a 20-year veteran of Chicago’s U.S. attorney’s office. He participated in the historic “Family Secrets” mob prosecution and faced off with gangsters such as Frank “The German” Schweihs and Michael “The Large Guy” Sarno. Now, Bhachu is chief of the office’s Public Corruption and Organized Crime Section.

What’s next: U.S. District Judge John Blakey signaled to jurors that all sides could finish presenting evidence by the end of this week, after roughly three months of trial — with the potential for closing arguments to begin as soon as Jan. 22.

Read more here.

Read Full Post »

By Hannah Meisel  | Capitol News Illinois

Over the last 2 ½ months, the jury in former Illinois House Speaker Michael Madigan’s corruption trial has heard the longtime Democratic leader’s voice dozens of times on wiretapped phone calls and in secretly recorded video footage.

Since October, jurors have seen the longtime powerbroker as he sat taking notes or otherwise watching testimony from nearly 60 witnesses from his seat at the head of his defense table in a wood-paneled federal courtroom.

But on Tuesday, the jury was finally able to fully observe Madigan – including the mannerisms and idiosyncratic speech patterns his attorney has accused the feds of willfully misinterpreting – as he took the stand in his own defense.

“Did you ever trade your public office for private gain?” Madigan attorney Dan Collins asked his client almost immediately after beginning his line of questioning early Tuesday afternoon.

“No,” Madigan said, turning to the jury as he gave his answer.

“Did you ever demand a thing of value in exchange for a promise to take official action?”

“No,” Madigan replied again before giving the same answer when asked if he’d ever accepted a “thing of value” in exchange for such a promise.

Collins repeated similar bursts of questions several more times before trial adjourned for the day, often pausing after the former speaker’s final denial, letting his “no” hang in the air before moving on to the next subject area.

Bribery charges

The repeated questions – and Madigan’s consistent answers – were aimed at refuting prosecutors’ main theory of bribery, which makes up nearly a third of the 23 counts Madigan faces. The indictment, first filed in March 2022 but expanded later that year, alleges Madigan helped electric utility Commonwealth Edison and telecom giant AT&T Illinois pass key legislation through Springfield in exchange for jobs and contracts for Madigan allies.

Additionally, prosecutors claim Madigan used his elected and political power to recruit clients for his property tax appeals law firm. The feds allege that Madigan – along with longtime Springfield lobbyist Mike McClain, who was indicted on six of the 23 counts – formed a “criminal enterprise” meant to enhance Madigan’s power in addition to enriching himself and those close to him.

Government lawyers have portrayed Madigan as an all-powerful leader who controlled an entire branch of state government as well as the political careers of hundreds of Democrats during his 36 years as House speaker. Meanwhile, Madigan’s attorneys have attempted to undermine that portrayal in their cross-examinations of 50 government witnesses and their defense case that began shortly before the holidays.

Madigan’s decision to testify furthers that work, but it’s a risky move. When prosecutors get their turn to cross-examine the former speaker as early as Wednesday, they will likely attempt to impeach him on the stand after Madigan directly contradicted testimony from several witnesses who’ve testified thus far.

Read more here.

Read Full Post »

The nation’s longest-serving legislative speaker, a woman who called herself “super mayor” and a collection of other self-serving public servants are among the highest-profile corruption cases in decades. Here’s the naughty list for 2024.

By Patrick Andriesen | Illinois Policy Institute

While most Illinoisans are preparing to share gifts, multiple probes into Illinois corruption remind us just how many powerful public servants wanted to receive gifts in 2024.

Ranked as the second-most corrupt state in the nation, Illinois’ corrupt politicians stand out in a crowded field for exploiting taxpayers’ good will. Here are some notable public corruption and misconduct cases from 2024.

Former Illinois House Speaker Michael Madigan

The nearly two-month-long federal corruption trial of former Illinois House Speaker Michael Madigan, the nation’s longest-serving legislative speaker, is predicted to come to a close in mid-January 2025.

Madigan is under indictment on 23-counts, including federal racketeering and bribery charges. Prosecutors allege Madigan ran a criminal enterprise, exchanging influence on key legislation for job opportunities for constituents and other allies.

The former speaker and his longtime political operative, Michael McClain, are accused of pressuring developers to hire Madigan’s law firm as well as conspiring with Commonwealth Edison and AT&T Illinois to provide no-work jobs for the speaker’s associates in return for legislative support in Springfield.

Court documents state Madigan netted $2.85 million in illegitimate funds.

Madigan’s current corruption trial follows a more than decade-long federal investigation into the former speaker that led to at least 21 individuals and businesses facing related criminal charges.

Madigan allies, including McClain, his former chief of staff and the “ComEd Four,” were found guilty by a federal court in 2023 in connection with Madigan’s patronage hiring scheme.

But Madigan denies all of it. He claimed jobs were given to his constituents because of good recommendations, not illegal influence.

Former state lawmaker Michael McClain

Former state lawmaker and longtime Springfield lobbyist Michael McClain is currently facing trial for a second time in the past two years for conspiring with Madigan to commit bribery and racketeering. McClain was Madigan’s long-time confidant and fixer.

McClain is currently facing trial on a 23-count indictment, including federal racketeering, bribery and wire fraud charges alongside his codefendant and longtime political ally, Madigan. McClain has pleaded “not guilty” to the charges.

McClain also denied wrongdoing as a defendant in the “ComEd Four” case before being found guilty in May 2023. He was convicted on all charges of conspiring to influence and reward Madigan for helping pass legislation favorable to Commonwealth Edison in Springfield.

Former Chicago Alderman Edward Burke

Once considered the most powerful alderman in Chicago, former 14th Ward Ald. Ed Burke was sentenced to two years in prison and fined $2 million in June 2024 after being convicted on all but one of the 14 counts of racketeering, attempted bribery, attempted extortion and other crimes.

Burke used his aldermanic powers and city finance committee chairmanship to divert business to his private tax law firm, Klafter & Burke, and shake down groups attempting to work with City Hall. The cigar-chomping, pinstripe-suited politician was in power for five decades.

The cases included threatening to block a proposed fee increase at the Field Museum, shaking down owners of a Burger King in his ward, accepting contracts for his personal law firm in return for support in the city council and blocking approval of the Chicago Post Office redevelopment until Klafter & Burke was hired by the developers.

The list (sadly) continues here.

Read Full Post »

Capitol News Illinois reporter Hannah Meisel is covering the corruption trial of ex-Illinois House Speaker Michael Madigan from the Dirksen Federal Courthouse in Chicago.

The former speaker, who left office under growing pressure related to the FBI investigation surrounding him in early 2021, faces 23 counts of racketeering, bribery, extortion and wire fraud.

To summarize, prosecutors allege he used his political power and various offices – including as a partner in his law firm – as a “criminal enterprise” to protect and enhance his power while enriching himself and his allies. But his defense attorneys argue the state is trying to criminalize the political process and baseline constituent services.

His co-defendant Mike McClain, a veteran Statehouse lobbyist and longtime Madigan confidant, was already convicted on public corruption charges last year in the separate but related “ComEd Four” trial.  The feds are again trying to show McClain is an “agent” of Madigan, while his defense attorneys say he simply engaged in legal relationship maintenance, a core function of lobbying

Below is a rundown of the coverage from the courtroom – where the trial is scheduled each Monday through Thursday well into December. This page will be updated as the trial progresses.

WEEK FIVE: NOV. 18 – 21 

Thursday, Nov. 21

Ex-Chicago Ald. Danny Solis, who secretly recorded Madigan for FBI, takes witness stand: As trial neared its conclusion for the week, ex-Chicago Ald. Danny Solis took the stand for what could be weeks of testimony. The star witness had cooperated with the FBI for years and told the jury that a bribery charge against him would be dropped if he testified against Madigan. The jury also learned that Solis’ wiretapped conversations with Madigan helped make the ex-speaker a target of the investigation in 2017, a year after Solis began cooperating. Read the story here.


Wednesday, Nov. 20

Madigan ally testifies he was rewarded with no-work contracts as ‘good soldier’ for speaker: Ed Moody held several political offices by the end of his career, thanks in large part to time he spent knocking doors on behalf of Madigan. He testified that Madigan and McClain helped him secure a $4,500 monthly contract through which he was paid indirectly by ComEd. Though he did little to no work for the utility, Moody said the payments were contingent on continuing his political work for Madigan. Read the story here.


Tuesday, Nov. 19

Wiretap: In pushing for Madigan-backed appointment, ex-ComEd CEO sought to ‘take good care’ of ‘our friend’: Chicago businessman Juan Ochoa, who was named to ComEd’s board after Madigan spent 1 ½ years pushing for the appointment, took the witness stand Tuesday. Jurors heard wiretaps regarding the appointment, including one of then-outgoing ComEd CEO Anne Pramaggiore telling McClain she set up a meeting between her replacement Ochoa. “You take good care of me, and so does our friend, and so I will do the best I can to take care of you,” she said. Read the story here.


Monday, Nov. 18

Madigan jury sees ‘Magic Lobbyist List’ seized from co-defendant during FBI search: McClain’s habit of printing out emails made FBI agents’ job a bit easier on May 14, 2019, as they searched his home office, another office area in the basement featuring a wall of filing cabinets and his car in the garage. The jury this week saw several of the seized documents from a series of coordinated raids, including McClain’s “magic list” of prominent Statehouse lobbyists with close ties to Madigan. Read the story here.

Coverage continues here.

For the full background on the trial, the yearslong investigation and Madigans’s fall from power, read Meisel’s preview story here: 4 decades after rising to power and nearly 4 years since his fall, former Speaker Madigan goes to trial

Read Full Post »

BARRINGTON HILLS – OCTOBER 31, 2024

State Representative Martin McLaughlin (R-Barrington Hills) issued the following statement after attending the ongoing corruption trial of former Speaker Mike Madigan.

Rep. McLaughlin said, “On this spooky day, as the trial of former Speaker Mike Madigan casts a shadow over Illinois politics, it’s clear that our state government needs to exorcise politicians who use the office to benefit themselves instead of for the benefit of the people.

“Today, I witnessed the corruption trial in person. The ruling Democrats of Illinois continue to undermine public trust, underscoring the urgent need for transparency and accountability in our political institutions.

Speaker Madigan’s long tenure has been plagued by allegations of bribery, influence peddling, and unethical practices that have eroded the faith of Illinoisans in their elected officials. The implications of this trial extend beyond one individual; they reveal the urgent necessity for reforms that restore integrity to our governance.”

The people of Illinois deserve a government that operates with the highest ethical standards. We must enact comprehensive reforms, including, but not limited to:

  • Independent Oversight: Establishing an independent ethics commission empowered to investigate misconduct and enforce ethical standards without political interference.
  • Campaign Finance Reform: Limiting contributions from individuals and organizations to reduce the influence of money in politics, ensuring equitable access for all constituents.
  • Conflict of Interest Laws: Defining and mandating reporting for conflicts of interest, ensuring lawmakers disclose any personal or financial interests that could influence their decisions.
  • Transparency in Government Contracts: Requiring public disclosure of all government contracts and expenditures, with detailed information on the bidding process to prevent favoritism and corruption.
  • Public Accountability Measures: Encouraging citizen engagement in the oversight process through public forums, advisory committees, and increased access to government meetings and documents.

As we move forward, it is essential for lawmakers to unite in prioritizing these crucial ethics reforms. The integrity of our government hinges on the trust of the people it serves, and Springfield politicians are falling far short of the minimum standards of governance.

Only through decisive action can we begin to rebuild that trust and ensure Illinois is governed by principles of honesty and responsibility. We urge all citizens to advocate for these reforms and hold their representatives accountable.

“Together, we can pave the way for a brighter, more transparent future for Illinois. This can only be achieved through meaningful reforms that bring true accountability back to the great people of Illinois,” concluded McLaughlin.

###

Read Full Post »

« Newer Posts - Older Posts »