
A copy of the budget recommendations sits on a desk after Mayor Brandon Johnson gave his address Oct. 21, 2026, at Chicago City Hall. | Brian Cassella/Chicago Tribune
By Ashlee B. Gabrysch | Special to the Tribune
I wasn’t born in Chicago, but I got here as soon as I could.
I arrived at 18, the first in my family to go to college, from a working-class Texas family that knew exactly what it meant when government showed up and when it didn’t. Chicago gave me an education, a profession, a home. For 15 years, I have studied this region’s finances from almost every angle, most recently as a credit analyst covering the city. On August 26, I had the honor of becoming the city’s chief financial officer.
Chicago gave me my first real winter and snow that had me frolicking. I worked out my future on the limestone at Promontory Point, looking across a lake so wide it might as well be an ocean, trying to imagine a life no one in my family had lived. I still catch my breath when my plane banks over the lakefront on the way home and downtown rises out of the water. But the city’s real beauty is its people: Chicagoans who say exactly what they mean, who show up for their block and their neighbors, and who come from every corner of the world and somehow make one city out of it.
On November 13, I resigned as CFO.
I knew the numbers were hard when I took the job. I left because I wouldn’t present them as anything less. Numbers don’t belong to any administration, and they shouldn’t be made to serve one.
Investors, rating agencies, City Council and taxpayers rely on what the CFO says about the city’s finances, and federal law holds those words to a high standard. Before I testified on this year’s budget, I committed in writing to answer every financial question plainly, without political spin. I kept that commitment.
Here is the problem: in the budget address and in a press conference afterwards, the mayor said 76% of this year’s budget fix is “structural,” meaning it solves the problem for good, rather than for one year. That’s only true if you leave out the money the city is borrowing to pay legal settlements, about a quarter of the total fix. When I testified, I counted that borrowing. I still do.
Chicago pays settlements every year, and borrowing to cover them doesn’t solve the budget’s structural problem. It kicks it into the future, with interest. The interest alone on the bonds proposed for 2027 will cost about $190 million, money that won’t go to a single library or clinic.
I couldn’t remain the official on whom investors, rating agencies, City Council and taxpayers rely while the city’s public description of its budget differed from its own published numbers. A CFO who can’t stand fully behind how the city’s finances are described should step aside. So I have.
Think of the city’s budget as a scale. On one side sit the things Chicago needs: safe streets, clean water, libraries, housing, help for people who are struggling. On the other side sit the resources to pay for them. Every program we add, however worthy, has weight. So do pensions, debt and the legal settlements we pay every year.
Ashlee Gabrysch, left, the chief financial officer for the City of Chicago, consults with Fiona A. Burke, deputy corporation counsel for the city, during a committee hearing at City Hall on Sept. 9, 2026. | Eileen T. Meslar/Chicago Tribune
For years, Chicago has kept that scale level by pressing a thumb on it: one-time revenue, using up our dwindling reserves, refinancing for upfront savings, borrowing to cover everyday spending like back pay and police misconduct settlements. A thumb holds the scale still for a moment, but it doesn’t fix the imbalance. When you lift it, the scale tips back, usually further than before.
That’s why presentation matters. When a budget looks healthier than it is, every new program looks affordable. This year’s budget adds new investments, many of them worthy, while relying on borrowing to pay for costs we already have. Making the numbers look better doesn’t make room for new commitments. It only hides how far the scale has already tipped.
The imbalance didn’t arrive last year or under any one mayor. It was built over decades. Saying so isn’t an argument against ambition. It’s the precondition for it. A city that can’t pay its bills can’t help the families who depend on it most, as mine once did. Fiscal discipline isn’t austerity. It’s protection. Budgets that hide borrowing don’t protect public investments. They guarantee deeper cuts and higher taxes later.
There is a way back, and it starts with agreeing on the numbers. The City Council, the administration, labor, business, and residents can disagree about what to fund and how to pay for it. We can’t afford to disagree about what things cost.
Whoever leads this City should commit to these principles:
- Show in every gap-closing plan how much of the gap is truly fixed for good, using the standard of the Government Finance Officers Association.
- Budget for settlements based upon actuarial analysis.
- Don’t borrow to pay everyday bills, even if we’ve done so in the past.
- Save money for the rainy day that will come.
- Treat every new commitment as a weight on the scale, not a line in a speech.
- Lift the thumb. Let the scale tell the truth.
That work depends on people whose job is to ask hard questions. The City Council and an independent press aren’t obstacles to good government: they’re essential to it.
Chicago has done hard things before. It reversed a river. It rebuilt itself after it burned to the ground. It earned the name the City That Works. It can work again.
This is my adopted home. I’ll be here, championing the people who do this work and the city that gave a working-class kid from Texas opportunities I never could have dreamed of. I will keep fighting for the truth, transparency and fiscal health our residents deserve, and that I know together we can achieve. I came to Chicago as soon as I could, and while I’m no longer your CFO, I’m not going anywhere.
Ashlee B. Gabrysch is the former chief financial officer of the City of Chicago.
