President McLaughlin
Trustee Konicek Hannigan
On Tuesday night, Barrington Hills Village President Martin McLaughlin and Trustee Colleen Konicek Hannigan were sworn in for their second terms, and the “Your Barrington Hills” (YBH) slate candidates Paula Jacobsen and Robert Zubak were sworn in for the first time.
In his opening remarks, President McLaughlin expressed his desire that board members, both old and new, would be working together in solving issues in a collaborative way and welcomed new ideas and initiatives. As hopeful and inclusive as his words were, we are not as optimistic that the new trustees will be anything more than a retread of the ideologies and failed policies espoused in past campaigns by former Village President Bob Abboud in 2009, the “Save Five Acres” slate in 2011 or the “Save Open Space” slate in 2015. In fact, most of the strategies employed by YBH in 2017 are directly out of the old regime’s playbook.
They employed the same strategy that Abboud did in his initial run for Village Presidency in 2005; create an issue (Save Five Acres), scare the residents with false allegations via a “ghost writer” (John Rosene), and impugn the character of those running against you. That technique was right out of the pages of “Rules for Radicals” by Saul Alinsky, the patron saint of morally bankrupt liberal politicians, who believe that the end justifies the means!
Recently joining in this assault on the unwary residents of the Village was Kristina Anderson with her inflammatory and inaccurate comments to the Board of Trustees at their April meeting, as chronicled in our article April 24th Board Meeting Recordings Released
In response to the proposed Plum Farm development in Hoffman Estates on land disconnected from the Village in 2004, Anderson created a Facebook group to oppose the development primarily due to its projected tax and student impacts to School District 220 & 300 taxpayers. We applaud her and other participating residents for speaking up at Hoffman Estates public meetings on this crucial issue – it’s often these types of grass-roots movements that can have great influence.
However, in addressing the Village Board, Anderson crossed the line between innuendo and untruthfulness a number of times. She presented herself as the beacon of truth, but she provided zero evidence for her wide-ranging allegations. Here are just a few examples:
- Allegation? Discontinuation of non-emergency police coverage. REALITY: Untrue. Residents’ access to a non-emergency number still exists today, seven days a week. It has never gone away. Chief Semelsberger described non-emergency call coverage during the April Board of Trustees meeting in detail. (see link. The only change is that after-hours non-emergency calls are now answered by Quad-com dispatchers, just as all village emergency 911 calls are. According to the Chief, these calls are answered by the same dispatch and our Barrington Hills officers respond as they always have if not engaged in true emergency situations.
- Allegation? Hills and Dales Farm [sic] and Cressey’s property are already zoned by McHenry County for less than five acre lots. REALITY: Untrue. The Duchossois’ Hill ‘N Dale Farm and the Cressey’s Cresswood Farm, both located in unincorporated McHenry County, are NOT zoned for less than five acre lots. They are not zoned for lots of any size at all! Both are zoned A-1 for agriculture. This is a fact that is easily looked up and disproven.
- Allegation? Board members haven’t declared their support for 5 acres. REALITY: Untrue. Every piece of literature from Colleen Konicek Hannigan and, Martin McLaughlin in 2013 and in 2017, and every piece of literature from Brian Croll, Michelle Maison and Brian Cecola in 2015 included a commitment to 5 acre zoning minimums. Over 5 years and in at least 12 mailers, each have each stated their support for five acre zoning. And every action by these five as members of the Board of Trustees has been consistent with maintaining this current zoning. There is not an ounce of truth to Ms. Anderson’s claims in this regard.
- Allegation? Board members have undisclosed interests with the Hoffman Estates Plum Tree Farms developers. REALITY: Untrue. This is such a blatantly false allegation it’s hard to even take this breathless advocate of the people seriously here. Anthony Iatarola does not have investors linked in ANY way to any members of the Board of Trustees. This claim is completely ridiculous, and, quite frankly, irresponsible.
- Allegation? President McLaughlin and the Board of Trustees have not been using all legal means at their disposal to object to the Plum Farms development. REALITY: Untrue. As described in the aforementioned Observer summary of the April 24th Board of Trustee Meeting synopsis, many discussions, both public and behind the scenes, have taken place with participation by McLaughlin, Village Attorneys, Village Administration, Trustee Michelle Maison and others. With regard to the oft-mentioned 1.5-mile planning jurisdiction, the village’s lawyers have explained that this does not apply in this instance because Barrington Hills and Hoffman Estates do not have a border agreement (despite several overtures by Barrington Hills in recent years). South Barrington has a legal right to object because it DOES have a border agreement with its neighbor. And due to McLaughlin’s excellent relationship with South Barrington President Paula McCombie, Barrington Hills has been able to sit in on meetings with South Barrington and offer input on strategy.
The simple facts are that open space and 5 acre zoning in Barrington Hills are not threatened by the incumbent Village President and Trustees. We are extremely disappointed that a resident, and an attorney no less, would stand up at a Board Meeting and make such unfounded allegations and insinuations. And, sadly, many of those allegations also came out of Jacobsen and Zubak’s YBH campaign and were eerily reminiscent of the Abboud-backed Save 5 Acres and Save Open Space campaigns. And we are left to wonder if Ms. Anderson was making her opening statement for a 2019 trustee run. We sincerely hope not.
Trustee Jacobsen
Trustee Zubak
So here we are, just one month after the village election, seeing the inflammatory campaign rhetoric continue. If Jacobsen and Zubak decide to adhere to the failed strategies and policies of the deposed Abboud regime, they will only continue to divide the community, and will sadly bring more harm to the equestrian community which they profess to support.
The Iatarola Property 1.5 Mile Myth:
Section 11-13-1 of the IL Municipal Code, 65 ILCS 5/11-13-1 et. seq. states that Illinois municipalities situtated in counties that have not adopted zoning ordinances affecting a parcel may exercise their municipal powers on such parcel for a distance of 1.5 miles beyond their corporate boundaries, provided that no part of such extraterritorial area is within another municipality.
Should the property within 1.5 miles of a municipality that exercises this extraterritorial zoning authority be annexed to another municipality, the latter’s zoning jurisidiction controls.
The Iatarola property has been annexed into Hoffman Estates and last time I checked Hoffman Estates has adopted a zoning ordinance placing Iatarola squarely under its jurisdiction. As I previoulsy stated, the time to “box-in” Iatarola was preferably before, but no later than during the disconnection lawsuit through negotiaton of mutual boundary agreement wtih Hoffman Estates and South Barrington restricting use of this eventual “unincorporated Cook County property” under the means of transitional zoning practices (‘feathering”) which would have insulated VBH border from further density creep and precluded the type of development which has now been proposed and approved for these 174 aces of land on our former Southern border.
Instead, elected yahoo 5 Acres village officials chose to fight a defenseless court battle resulting in loss of tens of thousands of VBH tax payer dollars (include Sears, excess of 1 Million Dollars ) as well as 174 acres on our Southern border with almost no defense to prevent further density creep.
In fact, the law firm selected by misguided 5-Acres BOT to fight Iatarola in the disconnection lawsuit is the same law firm now representing Iatarola on its annexation into Hoffman Estates and proposed dense housing development.
In 2011, I ran for VBH trustee, in part, warning residents of 5-Acres political team’s reckless border strategy and was villified by the likes of its political team chief propagandist “Honest John Rosene” for being a “featherer” at the expense of R-1 Zoning standards. They did this, irrespective of the fact that prior to 5 Acres misguided agenda, VBH elected officials throughout its history engaged in transitional zoning strategies on VBH borders through process of annexation, boundary agreements, land swaps and compromise of zoning standards not because it is always a perfect solution; but because it is smart.
You get the government you deserve and with 5-Acres we got what you voted for. Prior blogger Carrie is correct about the pension debacle as well as the “similar situations that have happened or are hiding in the tall grass waiting to happen”.
The good news is, I am confident President McLaughlin and Trustee Hannigan-Konicek are smart enough and will do everything in their power as elected officials to try and stem the bleeding (much of which resulting from 5 Acres unforced errors) by doing what is right rather than what may be most popular or create the best sound bite for the next election.